Designing Global Surgical Technology: Benefits of a Participatory Design Approach for the Surgeon

1st International Congress for Innovation in Global Surgery

doi: 10.52648/ICIGS.1000_49

Designing Global Surgical Technology: Benefits of a Participatory Design Approach for the Surgeon

Tim Ho , Millie Marriot-Webb, William Bolton, Noel Aruparayil, Peter Culmer
University of Leeds, Leeds, United Kingdom

Introduction: Participatory Design (PD) is an approach to technology development that aims to improve outcomes through close and equal involvement of stakeholders in the development process. This approach is increasingly prevalent in medical technology development – particularly in Global Surgery and low-resource healthcare interventions, where understanding of the clinical context is vital to design. It has been argued that PD projects should prioritize participant outcomes alongside project objectives to ensure project longevity and success, yet there is a paucity of research regarding the impacts on clinical stakeholders, and how to optimise their collaboration. Better understanding of the benefits for clinical stakeholders will help facilitate these aims and promote better collaborations.

Methodology: Clinical stakeholders, involved in the development of the “RAIS” (Retractor for Abdominal Insufflation-less Surgery) device, were identified for interview. Semi-structured interviews were conducted with each participant to ascertain their personal motivations, experiences of multidisciplinary and international collaboration, and to explore any opportunities or skills that were developed. Personal frustrations and barriers to collaboration were identified and solutions to these concerns explored.

Results: Stakeholders unanimously prioritised clinical results over personal enrichment as the primary motivation for participation, though academic and career opportunities were recognised as key benefits. A non-hierarchical relationship between clinical and design teams allowed the clinicians to contribute and influence the design process to meet their specific needs as the device’s intended users. The geographical distance between teams and the lengthy design process were major sources of frustration. However, effective communication channels, and integration into design considerations, reduced miscommunication and enhanced contributions from the surgical team who were able to provide more detailed and valuable feedback.

Discussion: This study aims to catalyse further research to determine the ideal participant and project outcomes and the optimal approach to facilitate these. Key considerations for innovators considering using a PD approach include:
Project Conception:
1. Prioritize input from a variety of stakeholders based in LMIC’s in the initial design phase
2. Collaborate with local stakeholders throughout the design process to ensure continuity
3. Establish stakeholder-specific goals as part of the project’s objectives
4. Communicate interactively to understand the context and form collaborative relationships with stakeholders
5. Espouse an ethos of equal stakeholdership to facilitate bi-directional information flow, encourage feedback and ensure participant motivations
6. Validate interventions with stakeholders in the contextual environment
7. Support the development of innovation networks and capacities within LMIC’s
8. Empower stakeholders to innovate, collaborate and disseminate their knowledge
9. Employ formal PD frameworks to guide long-term and sustainable stakeholdership

No figures
Inaugural Speech: Surgery in the face of low resources

Use of autologous platelet rich fibrin in minimally invasive treatment of perianal abscess

Machine Learning based mortality prediction model for COVID-19 patients admitted in a tertiary care hospital, New Delhi.

Perceived impact of trauma audit filters on trauma care in a tertiary care hospital: a qualitative analysis

An innovative surgical method to operate the zygomatico-maxillary-orbital complex in the absence of intraoperative computer tomography or intraoperative navigation using novel zygoma analysis and virtual surgical planning software

Carica papaya fruit in the management of chronic non healing ulcer wounds

The Buddy System: An initiative to slow down the antibiotic misuse

SOCH – India (Students’ Orbit for Collaborative Healthcare – India)

Need of an Autopsy Kit in resource limited settings

Device for non-invasive detection of meconium stained amniotic fluid

A Novel Stethoscope In COVID 19 Times

Explainable AI decision model for ECG data of cardiac disorders

Satyanveshi: A New Age Mentorship Program in Medical School

Predict Easy :Pre-eclampsia Risk Stratification Tool

SutureSure-A multifunctional laparoscopic device for simple and effortless minimally invasive surgeries

RI2 -Retract, Isolate, and Illuminate: 3 in 1 Affordable solution for effective Community Dental Program

A new approach to stoma management

Neonatal care platform to facilitate the practice of delayed cord clamping

Urine congophilia dipstick test for preeclampsia screening in resource limited settings

Lap-Pack: a low fidelity laparoscopic box trainer


Innovative multi-modality segmentation and 3d fusion in the management of giant abdominopelvic chondrosarcoma

Malunited lateral tibial plateau fracture managed by intra-articular osteotomy with help of 3D printing

SurgiPod -The Smallest Portable Modular OT

Doctors On Community Service -An attempt to shift focus from Classroom to Community among medical students

Automatic Uterine Incision closure device

Aerosol Evacuation Funnel

OsteQuant -A comprehensive bone age and bone health estimation tool

Efficacy of local application of colistimethate sodium in non-healing wounds infected by multidrug resistant bacteria


MeeT: A Platform for Innovation

The Metaverse as a platform for education and training within medicine and surgery

An inexpensive surgical glove bag for gall bladder retrieval during laproscopic cholecystectomy

Frugal indigenous methods for chest tube insertion and venesection

Digital videoproctoscopy: a new diagnostic test in proctology

Identifying palliative care needs for tribal-rural populations

Training 750 General surgeons in this decade for district hospitals in Kenya

Feasibility of the frugally-engineered ‘LeVe CPAP’ from pilot data in healthy volunteers at Mengo Hospital, Uganda; with potential for use in patients with acute hypoxaemic respiratory failure associated with COVID-19 and other respiratory illnesses

The RAIS device for low-resource laparoscopic surgery: development, evaluation and future perspectives

Introduction of WALANT in Kenya: An innovative method to alleviate poverty

Condition monitoring of Ilizarov frames using vibration sensors

The Impact of Gurukool on College Students, Residents, Faculties, and Campus life in a Medical College of New Delhi

Efficacy of Platelet-Rich Plasma in Reduction of Post-Operative Split-Thickness Skin Graft Loss and Hematoma Formation: A Meta-Analysis

Spontaneous common bile duct perforation presenting as extrahepatic bilioma: a rare clinical presentation of gall stone disease

External Fixation in Polytrauma Patients from Low and Middle Income Countries – A Case Report

Lumbar Disc Degeneration, A Transdifferentiation Process-An Electron Microscopic Observation

Designing Global Surgical Technology: Benefits of a Participatory Design Approach for the Surgeon

Music as an adjunct cost-effective therapeutic innovation for Management of Pain in Trauma Patients: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis

System Innovation in Laparoscopic Simulation Training for intra-corporeal tissue re-approximation, knot tying and suturing technologies

Reverse Innovation in Healthcare from India

Expressed breast milk: Awareness and opinion on storage and utilization among mothers in tertiary health care center, Belagavi

A New Innovation in Yogasan (A new Yogasan for quick relief of tension and sleeplessness)

A Comparative Study of Ripasa Scoring System and Ultrasonography in the Clinical diagnosis of the Acute Appendicitis in Resource Limited Settings